Select Page

Subscription services have been making headway in the FMCG space of late, accounting for 20% of all e-commerce orders in that category. But how many online shoppers subscribe to broader e-commerce subscription services – and why? A McKinsey survey offers some insights.

Here are 5 key takeaways from the report.

1. 15% of Online Shoppers Have Subscribed to An E-Commerce Service in the Past Year

McKinsey’s survey demonstrates that 15% of online shoppers have subscribed to a subscription-box service in the past year. Most of those (11 of the 15%) also have subscribed to a media service such as Netflix or Spotify, which are more 3 times more popular (46% share of online shoppers having subscribed).

2. Subscribers Skew Towards Women, But Men Have More Services

The analysis indicates that subscription-box services have more appeal among women, who account for 60% of subscribers.

However, male subscribers are 50% more likely than their female counterparts to have 3 or more current subscriptions (42% and 28%, respectively).

In fact, fully 18% of male subscribers claim to be subscribed to at least 6 e-commerce services, compared to just 7% of female subscribers.

Overall, a strong majority (58%) of e-commerce service subscribers have multiple active subscriptions.

In other demographic data, McKinsey reveals that, compared to the US population at-large, e-commerce subscribers are more likely to be ages 25-44, have incomes from $50-100k, and live in urban environments in the Northeast.

3. Amazon Subscribe & Save Is the Most Popular Service

The report points out that men and women tend to subscribe to different services. However, the top-2 are consistent (albeit in different order) across both genders.

For women, Amazon Subscribe & Save is the most popular service, followed by Dollar Shave Club. Those are men’s top services also, although in reverse order.

Amazon Subscribe & Save comes out on top overall, followed by Dollar Shave Club, Ipsy (#3 for women, not in the top 10 for men), Blue Apron (#4 for men, # 7 for women) and Birchbox (#4 for women, #7 for men).

The leading service – Amazon Subscribe & Save – falls in the “replenishment” category, one of three general categories for these services. This category – in which the services replenish the same or similar commodity items – accounts for roughly one-third (32%) of e-commerce subscriptions.

The most popular category is the domain of curation. These services comprise 55% of respondents’ subscriptions – and include Birchbox, Blue Apron and Stitch Fix. The analysts note that the popularity of these services – in which subscribers receive a curated selection of items – “suggests a strong desire for personalized services.”

The last category – “subscribe for access” – is the least popular, comprising 13% of subscriptions. Its primary value is offering exclusive access to subscribers, and the leading service within the category is JustFab.

4. The Experience Counts. A Lot.

Subscribers offer different reasons for purchasing and cancelling subscriptions, depending on the type of service.

When asked the single most important trigger when initiating a subscription:

  • Wanting to try something new (25%) was the top response for curation subscriptions;
  • A financial incentive (24%) was cited most often for replenishment subscriptions; and
  • A recommendation (24%) was the most-cited reason for access subscriptions.

As for the most important reason to continue a subscription:

  • Personalized experience (28%) was easily the top vote-getter for curation and access subscriptions; while
  • Convenience (24%) edged value for the money (23%) and a personalized experience (22%) for replenishment subscriptions.

Clearly a personalized experience counts. But so does a poor experience.

Asked the single most important driver of a subscription cancellation, respondents pointed to:

  • Value for the money (29%) first for curation subscriptions, closely followed by dissatisfaction with the product and/or experience (27%);
  • Dissatisfaction with the product/experience (24%) first for replenishment subscriptions; and
  • Value for the money (29%) first for access subscriptions, with product/experience dissatisfaction and a preference to buy when in need as joint-second.

5. Churn Rate? Roughly 40%.

Possibly the most important metric for subscription service companies is their churn rate.

It’s true that acquisition is also a challenge: McKinsey’s survey found that just 53% of online shoppers even knew about one of the top services. Further, only 55% of those considering a service ultimately subscribed, making conversions a challenge. (Free trials could offer a helping hand, per Recurly research.)

Ultimately, though, these services have to retain their subscribers. And that’s proving a difficult proposition. Overall, 39% of respondents reported having churned from a subscription, ranging from a low of 30% for replenishment subscribers to a high of 46% for access subscribers.

The full report can be found here.

About the Data: The results are based on a survey of 5,093 consumers in the US, of whom 80% (4,053) qualified as online shoppers, having spent at least $25 online in the prior month.

Of those online shoppers, 607 (15%) had subscribed to at least one e-commerce service over the past 12 months.

Feel Like You're Always Playing Catchup?

Stay ahead of the curve with our free newsletter. It’s fast. It’s factual. And it’s clear

marketing charts logo

Error: Please enter a valid email address

Error: Invalid email

Error: Please enter your first name

Error: Please enter your last name

Error: Please enter a username

Error: Please enter a password

Error: Please confirm your password

Error: Password and password confirmation do not match